Could using the zona pellucida bound sperm for intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI) enhance the outcome of ICSI?

I n the recent literature, several interesting articles have been published using the zona pellucdia (ZP)-bound sperm for intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI) to enhance embryo quality, implantation and clinical pregnancy rates. The three studies were performed independently in different ART clinics. In the test group, patients’ sibling immature (either germinal vesicle (GV) or metaphase I) oocytes were used to harvest the ZP-bound sperm, which were used for injection of mature oocytes. In the control group, ICSI patients with similar female age and sperm profiles had ICSI with standard sperm selection by the embryologist subjectively choosing the sperm. The results showed that the proportion of high-quality embryos (grades 1 and 2) and implantation rates were higher with ICSI using ZP-bound sperm than with conventional sperm selection. More pregnancies were achieved in the ZP-bound sperm group although clinical (fetal heart detected) pregnancy rates did not reach statistical significance between the two groups, likely due to small sample sizes. These preliminary reports suggest that ZPselected sperm appear to be superior to subjectively selected sperm for ICSI. If this finding can be further verified by a large clinical study, the use of the ZP-bound sperm for ICSI could be applied more widely in ICSI to enhance pregnancy outcome. In the literature, some studies have been reported that in vitro fertilization (IVF) embryos produced relatively higher implantation and clinical pregnancy rates compared to ICSI embryos. It is possible that some ICSI patients with low implantation or pregnancy may result from injection of inadequate or poor-quality sperm, for example, with abnormal morphological or DNA damaged sperm. As the majority of ICSI patients are male factor infertility and they have variable abnormal ejaculated sperm, particularly those with high proportion of DNA damaged sperm, subjective manual method is inconsistent or unable to select a most competent sperm for ICSI. Thus it is necessary to develop an objective and efficient method for selection of the most competent sperm for ICSI. Over the many years since ICSI was first introduced in 1992, ICSI has been using the same sperm preparation methods as conventional IVF, such as swim-up or discontinuous density gradients centrifugation. These classic methods are predominately designed to harvest large numbers of motile sperm and to eliminate non-sperm cells and debris. However, these sperm preparation methods are less or not effective in the selection of sperm with normal morphology and normal DNA. For conventional IVF, it is adequate to inseminate oocytes using motile sperm selected by these methods since the sperm which fertilizes will be further selected through the biological process of sperm– oocyte interaction, especially sperm–ZP binding. In contrast with conventional ICSI, this additional selection does not occur. The embryologists subjectively select a sperm based only on motility and gross morphology and it is very difficult to select a most competent sperm for injection of an oocyte, in particular for samples with high proportion of DNA damaged sperm. The manual selection of sperm for ICSI is very subjective and inconsistent within and between embryologists. Although many other different sperm preparation methods have been developed to improve sperm preparation for ICSI, for example, hyaluronic acid (HA) binding and high magnification of microscope combined with computer enlarged image for selection of morphologically normal sperm, clinical application of these new methods have not been well evaluated and it is unknown if they are better than the conventional method. It is reported that sperm bound to HA have better morphology and less DNA damage, but using the HA bound sperm for ICSI does not significantly improve implantation and pregnancy. As the ability of sperm binding to the HA is mainly based on enzyme activity of hyaluronidase which is on the surface of all motile sperm, the majority (.85%) of motile sperm are capable of binding to the HA. In human ejaculate from fertile men, although an average ejaculate contains 100– 200 million motile sperm, only about 14% motile sperm are capable of binding to the human ZP in vitro. Therefore, there is a very small proportion of motile sperm in human ejaculate that has the capacity of binding to the ZP. Clearly, only those sperm bound to the ZP have a chance to penetrate the ZP and then fertilize the oocyte either in vivo or IVF conditions. Thus the majority of motile sperm in ejaculate have no real fertilizing ability in vivo or IVF condition. Although the ability of sperm binding to the ZP is not necessary and likely only a viable sperm with normal DNA is needed for fertilization with ICSI, many previous studies showed clearly that the human ZP selectively binds sperm with normal morphology. The majority of sperm (average .92%) bound to the ZP have normal nuclear chromatin DNA. These results suggest that the human ZP possesses the capacity to select normal functioning sperm and therefore, the ZP-bound Melbourne IVF, East Melbourne, Vic. 3002, Australia and Department of Obstetrics and Gynaecology, University of Melbourne, Parkville, Vic. 3052, Australia Correspondence: Dr D Y Liu ([email protected]) Asian Journal of Andrology (2011) 13, 197–198 2011 AJA, SIMM & SJTU. All rights reserved 1008-682X/11 $32.00